ABSTRACT Objective: To determine the performance of groups of pediatric residents from a Buenos Aires hospital, in terms of correct recognition and communication of a medical error (ME), in a high-fidelity simulation scenario. To describe the reactions and communication attempts following the ME and the self-perception by the trainees before and after a debriefing. Methods: Quasi-experimental uncontrolled study conducted in a simulation center. First- and third-year pediatric residents participated. We designed a simulation case in which an ME occurred and the patient deteriorated. During the simulation, participants had to provide information on communicating the ME to the patient’s father. We assessed communication performance and, additionally, participants completed a self-perception survey about ME management before and after a debriefing. Results: Eleven groups of residents participated. Ten (90.9%) identified the ME correctly, but only 27.3% (n=3) of them reported that a ME had occurred. None of the groups told the father they were going to give him important news concerning his son’s health. All 18 residents who actively participated in this communication completed the self-perception survey, with an average score before and after debriefing of 5.00 and 5.05 (out of 10) (p=0.88). Conclusions: We observed a high number of groups that recognized the presence of a ME, but the communication action was substantially low. Communication skills were insufficient and residents’ self-perception of error management was regular and not modified by the debriefing.

RESUMO Objetivo: Determinar o desempenho de grupos de residentes pediátricos de um hospital de Buenos Aires, em termos de reconhecimento e comunicação correta de um erro médico (EM),em cenário de simulação. Descrever as reações e tentativas de comunicação após o EM e a autopercepção pelos estagiários antes e depois de um questionário. Métodos: Estudo quase experimental não controlado realizado em centro de simulação. Participaram residentes pediátricos do primeiro e terceiro anos. Concebeu-se um caso de simulação em que ocorreu um EM com deterioração de um paciente. Durante a simulação, os participantes tiveram que fornecer informações relacionadas à comunicação do EM ao pai do paciente. Avaliou-se o desempenho da comunicação e, adicionalmente, os participantes completaram um inquérito de autopercepção sobre a gestão da EM, antes e depois de um questionário. Resultados: Onze grupos de residentes participaram. Dez (90,9%) identificaram corretamente o EM, mas apenas 27,3% (n=3) deles comunicaram que havia ocorrido o EM. Nenhum dos grupos disse ao pai que iria dar notícias importantes sobre a saúde do seu filho. Todos os 18 residentes que participaram ativamente da comunicação completaram o questionário de autopercepção com uma pontuação média antes e depois do questionário de 5,00 e 5,05 (máximo: 10 pontos) (p=0,88). Conclusões: Observamos elevado número de grupos que reconheceram a presença de um EM, mas a ação de comunicação foi rara. A capacidade de comunicação foi insuficiente e a autopercepção da gestão de erros por parte dos residentes foi regular, não sendo modificada pelo debriefing.

Introduction. The Mini-Clinical Evaluation Exercise (Mini-CEX) is a formative tool with two descriptors assessing the inquiry of vaccination status and the hierarchy of prevention opportunities. Objectives. Determine the prevalence of both items in pediatric controls and spontaneous demands. Compare the performance between first and third year of their training. Material and methods. Retrospective analysis based on trainees Mini-CEX charts. Results. There were 119 residents evaluated during their first year. The prevalence of vaccination status screening in controls was 94.9% (confidence interval -CI-: 91.09-98.91); in demands 73.1% (CI: 65.2-81; OR 5.33; CI: 2.2312.75; p 0.00004). The prevalence of prevention opportunities in controls was 69.8% (CI: 61.678); in demands 62.2% (CI: 53.5-70.9; OR 1.034; CI: 0.4638-2.306; p= 0.4673). There were 32 trainees compared between their first and third year performance in demands, without significant difference. Conclusions. We found high prevalence of vaccination inquiry and lower prevalence of hierarchization of prevention opportunities in controls, with less inquiry in demands.

Introducción. El Mini-Clinical Evaluation Exercise (Mini-CEX) es una herramienta formativa. Dentro de sus ítems, evalúa la pesquisa del estado de vacunación y la jerarquización de oportunidades de prevención. Objetivos. Determinar porcentaje de pesquisa de dichos ítems en controles de salud y demanda. Comparar desempeño entre primer y tercer año. Materiales y métodos. Análisis retrospectivo de las planillas del Mini-CEX de residentes. Resultados. Se evaluaron 119 residentes. La prevalencia de pesquisa de vacunación en controles fue 94,9% (intervalo de confianza -IC-: 91,09-98,91); en demanda, 73,1% (IC: 65,2-81; OR 5,33; IC: 2,23-12,75; p= 0,00004). La prevalencia de aprovechamiento de oportunidades en controles fue 69,8% (IC: 61,6-78); en demanda, 62,2% (IC: 53,5-70,9; OR 1,034; IC: 0,46382,306; p= 0,4673). En 32 residentes se comparó su desempeño entre primer y tercer año en demandas, sin diferencia significativa. Conclusiones. Se detectó alta prevalencia de pesquisa de vacunación y menor prevalencia de aprovechamiento de oportunidades en controles, con menor pesquisa de ambos ítems en demandas.

Saint Louis encephalitis is transmitted by Culex mosquitoes. In Argentina sporadic cases are registered. Symptomatic illness is unusual in children. We present a case of meningoencephalitis caused by an uncommon viral infection. The clinical signs and symptoms are unusual for pediatric patients and the bilateral thalamic compromise showed on magnetic resonance has not been described previously. An 8-year-old girl consulted due to fever, behavior disorders and ataxia. Clonus and neck stiffness were detected at physical exam. Cerebrospinal fluid revealed mononuclear leukocytosis; bilateral ischemic compromise was observed in thalamus by magnetic resonance. Saint Louis virus was confirmed by serology: serum and cerebrospinal fluid IgM were positive during the acute phase of the disease and serum IgG was positive four weeks later. Most of the signs and symptoms of the disease were resolved, however mild behavior disorders were observed as acute sequelae up to 45 days after hospital discharge.

La encefalitis por el virus de Saint Louis es una enfermedad que se transmite a través de mosquitos de la especie Culex.En Argentina, se registran casos esporádicos, habitualmente asintomáticos en niños. Se presenta el caso de una paciente con manifestaciones clínicas inusuales en edad pediátrica y lesiones en el sistema nervioso central no descritas hasta el momento en la literatura. Se trata de una niña de 8 años, que consultó por síndrome febril, cambios conductuales, ataxia, clonus y rigidez de nuca. En el líquido cefalorraquídeo, se detectó pleocitosis predominantemente mononuclear. Se realizó una resonancia magnética, que evidenció imágenes de isquemia bitalámica. La infección por virus de Saint Louis se diagnosticó por IgM en el suero y el líquido cefalorraquídeo. La paciente evolucionó de manera favorable. Al momento del egreso hospitalario, persistía con bradipsiquia y alteraciones conductuales y se recuperó definitivamente 45 días después del alta.

The Mini Clinical Evaluation Exercise (Mini-CEX) is an assessment tool, which emphasizes the educational value and is based on direct performance observation. The objective was to evaluate the reliability and feasibility of Mini-CEX using pediatric descriptors during its implementation in two pediatric residency programs. The design was observational, exploratory and feasibility in the use of this evaluation tool. Based on the original format, descriptors related to the pediatric consult for each Mini-CEX dimension´s were agreed. Operators were trained in the use of this tool by means of descriptors as well as in debriefing strategies. Finally, there were two simultaneous and independent evaluations for each observation. Analysis: a) Mini-CEX global and dimension score; b) Concordance between operators scores (mean differences and 95% CI); c) Non evaluable descriptors frequency; d) Duration and satisfaction in use. There were 80 observations in 40 pediatric consults. Overall score 7.5 ± 0.9 (6.4 ± 2 to 8.3 ± 1.1 depending on dimension), with no significant differences between the two institutions. There was high agreement between observers (Mean, difference between 0.1 and 0.3, 95% CI -0.8 to 0.3). The frequency of non evaluable descriptors ranged 5-28 (9% to 51%) and it was not associated with the implementation stage. The average implementation time was 20 minutes, and satisfaction in use was high among both operators and residents. Mini-CEX tool using pediatric descriptors showed high reliability. The joint experience was satisfactory and simultaneously confirmed the value of debriefing.

El Mini Clinical Evaluation Exercise (Mini-CEX) es una herramienta formativa de evaluación aplicada durante la observación directa del desempeño en la clínica. Nuestro objetivo fue evaluar la confiabilidad y factibilidad del Mini-CEX utilizando descriptores pediátricos en dos programas de residencia de pediatría. El diseño fue de tipo observacional y corte transversal. Se consensuaron descriptores de la consulta pediátrica para cada una de las dimensiones del Mini-CEX. Los operadores fueron capacitados en el uso de esta herramienta por medio de descriptores, así como en las estrategias informativas. Finalmente, se realizaron 2 evaluaciones independientes y simultáneas por cada observación de desempeño. Análisis: a) Puntaje global y por dimensión del Mini-CEX, b) Concordancia de puntajes entre operadores (promedios de diferencias e IC95%); c) Frecuencias de descriptores no evaluables y d) Duración y satisfacción en su uso. Se realizaron 80 observaciones en 40 consultas pediátricas. Puntaje global 7.5 ± 0.9 (6.4 ± 2 a 8.3 ± 1.1 según dimensión), sin diferencias significativas entre instituciones. Se observó alta concordancia entre observadores (Media, diferencia 0.1 a 0.3; IC 95% -0.8 a 0.3). La frecuencia de descriptores no evaluables fue 5 a 28 (9% a 51%) y no se asoció con el lugar de aplicación. El tiempo promedio de implementación fue 20 minutos. El uso resultó altamente satisfactorio para docentes y residentes. Se implementó el Mini-CEX luego de consensuar descriptores de la consulta pediátrica. La experiencia conjunta fue satisfactoria y a la vez confirmó el valor de la evaluación y entrega de sus resultados: la devolución formativa.